Sky, I think you should make a rule that you can't "undo" what people did. Player 1 » Event A happenedPlayer 2 » Event A didn't really happen
Unfortunately they found evidence anyway and he was convicted, and was sentenced to a hanging on one weekday but it would be a surprise, good luck
Fortunately, on the day of the hanging, Robin Hood was there and shot an arrow to snap the rope to prevent death. Also, try not to completely contradict others.
Unfortunately, they were both captured by the guards and were both sentenced to be hung the next day.