[SUGGESTION] Res rating.

Discussion in 'Suggestion Box Archives' started by varkz, Dec 16, 2012.


Is this a good idea?

Yes! Its amazing 7 vote(s) 77.8%
Nah, Boring 1 vote(s) 11.1%
Woah... (; 1 vote(s) 11.1%
  1. Hey guys.

    So i was just on Utopia looking at all the fantastic residents and then i was like.. "Wouldn't it be awesome if you could like rate a res and when you walk onto the res or you teleport to the res instead of saying "Welcome to blah res" it would say "Welcome to blah res, rating *****" the * would actually be stars though. Do you guys think that would be cool? your stars would depend on how many ratings you got and how many stars each rating was like you could go to a res and rate it using /rate res **** if it was 4 *'s.

    What do you guys think? Has this already been suggested? if it has im sorry i didnt see it :3
  2. Who would rate them?
  3. The community, EVERYONE and ANYONE :D or you could do it with only supporters or only if you've never been banned or something like that
  4. Why not on the other smp's?
  5. Its on every server but he thought of it on Utopia
    varkz likes this.
  6. Seems good idea, as long as the res owner's can disable/enable the rating on his/her res.
    nfell2009 and varkz like this.
  7. What Jakres says. Or at least, it shouldn't be enabled by default. Because, you see, imagine you just started and you build a simple wood or cobble hut to start gathering materials, you start planning, setting the base of your buildings, and at that very moment someone visits you. There's very... uhm, "slow" people who won't think twice before rating your res when it's under construction.

    But yes, the whole idea is good, something similar to the TEXP Leaderboards but with our buildings.
    varkz likes this.
  8. Yes i agree this is a good idea but you should have to ability to turn it off because not everyone might want a rating and another problem i see is that if someone has had a argument with a person then one of the people that argued might just rate the persons res 1 star and get other people to rate it low just because of a silly argument (I saw this on smp4 the other day) If that makes sense anyway :) However i still like the idea :D
    varkz likes this.
  9. I had nothing to do with that :rolleyes:

    Also, I like the idea. But what about trolls? People going round doing: (lets say the command is)

    /res vote 1
    /res vote 1
    /res vote 1
    /res vote 1

    On every res they visit?
    _Stads_ and Jake_bagby like this.
  10. I in fact suggested this a few months back (I think back in April 2012) and ultimately it was decided a bad idea as people with alts would ultimately destroy the system. Even with a cap of voting and such it just wouldn't work :/ I do love this Idea though :D
  11. IrThanks for the link Stads. I see all the problems pointed out, it just seems to be difficult to set a system secured and fair. I can think of a few solutions to it, some very simple and some a bit more complicated. It's a pitty but well, the Creations forum and the showcasde threads going on can make up for it.