It has been accepted and posted about several times! PIE HAS WON THE WAR! for the most part Just read this: http://empireminecraft.com/threads/we-must-end-this.30898/
While I now support pie it has not won yet. Bacon is the overall winner (cookies is also tied with bacon).
And who decides which post are better than the others and which arguments are better? There could be 100 posts saying 'pies are more delicious' and then there could be 4 posts that go in depth about how muffins are better. So who wins? and who decides?