I need your help for this. I really have no idea. I really want to do the public melons... It's pretty cool. Also, for reference it's 227 on SMP1 in case it affects you in some way. Thanks.
The way it's looking it will probably be a melon farm. Congratz SMP1, free melons! Well five stacks for 1r but whatever.
I like the melon idea and the villager trading. When it comes to enchants and stuff in particular a public villager post would be really cool to have on smp1. Let me know when it's up and running, I will add it to the smp1s public directory/tp hub at 2112.
I may do both... I was only planning on the melons to be underground so above ground I'm totally open still.