Was this supposed to be an auction? You need to be careful in the way you do these kinds of sales. You had a willing buyer reply to your thread here, but you went and sold it to another player. Just a note for next time: When you hold an auction/sale on the forums, make sure you are following the right format and post it in the subforum dedicated to Auctions Eliminates the possibility of disagreements and misunderstandings. I'll post the appropriate format for an auction below. Auction format: Title: [AUCTION] *name & enchantment of the pic* Description *same as the title* Condition *brand new/never used is the best way to sell an item* Starting Bid *such as 1000k* Minimum Bid Increments *200r* Auction End *in so many hours/24 hours after the last bidder bids etc* I'm sure you could do this for a straight out sale too, but instead of saying the minimum bid and when the auction ends, tell the players the first person to reply with a serious intent to buy will get the product. Just remember to kep a check on the forum thread you've started before you sell it to someone else